Google tells CMOs to kill the generic 'Top 10' post, and SEOs push back on the metrics, not the content
A Nov. 19 post sent CMOs back to a Google ad executive's October essay on AI search, and SEOs agreed with the content advice but not the metrics behind it.

Google's own Think with Google account told CMOs on Nov. 19 that AI didn't make their brand invisible in search — their content did. The post urged marketers to retire the generic "Top 10" list and lead instead with first-hand expertise, linking back to an October essay from a Google ad executive, and it set off a debate among SEOs that split cleanly: agreement on the content advice, and skepticism about the measurement Google wants marketers to trust instead. For software marketers who have spent years publishing roundup posts to rank for commodity keywords, both halves of that debate matter.
What changed
The Nov. 19 post came from Google's official marketing account on X and linked to a piece Brendon Kraham, Google's VP of Search & Commerce Global Ads Solutions, published on Think with Google in October. Kraham's argument is that AI search hasn't narrowed the buyer's journey, it's lengthened it: people using AI-assisted search now hit roughly three times as many touchpoints as they did before, and a large majority say the AI features help them decide faster, according to a Google-commissioned Ipsos survey of online shoppers cited in the piece. Kraham lists three priorities he hears from CMOs — track the "super-empowered consumer," build authority through unique expertise, and tie plans to business outcomes.
The "Top 10" line sits inside the second priority. Kraham's example: instead of a running store publishing a generic "Top 10 Things to Consider," it should publish a deep-dive on why one specific customer's shoes failed. That's the same distinction Google Search's own generative-AI guide draws, which calls a post like "7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers" commodity content and contrasts it with a first-hand account of waiving a home inspection, as Search Engine Journal reported.
Kraham's essay backs the point with two examples from brands he names directly. Daniel Shin Un Kang, head of organic and agentic search at Expedia Group, told Think with Google that the medium changed but the goal didn't: search moved "from keywords to conversations," while the underlying work of answering a traveler's question stayed the same. IKEA's deputy CMO, Linda Ha, described a similar shift in how the retailer plans kitchen content, saying the newer search experience lets IKEA connect its in-house expertise to shoppers mid-project instead of waiting for them to search a generic category term. Neither example is about ranking for a keyword; both are about having an answer a generic post wouldn't contain.
Why the pushback is about metrics, not listicles
SEO practitioners who saw the Nov. 19 post online largely agreed with the content advice itself. Lily Ray, founder of Algorythmic, reacted by writing, "Wow did Google really just tell CMOs to stop with the top 10 listicles?" according to Search Engine Journal's reporting on her post. The sharper objection came from growth advisor Eli Schwartz, who posted his own blunter paraphrase of Kraham's three points and, next to the point about tying content to business outcomes rather than unproven metrics, wrote "AEO visibility is not real." Siege Media founder Ross Hudgens went further, replying to Ray that the self-promotional "best" list Google didn't name was the bigger problem, not the generic tips post it did name. Ray has tracked that pattern separately: an earlier column of hers reported that AI Overviews frequently cite companies' own self-ranking "best" lists alongside competitor recommendations — exactly the content neither Kraham's essay nor Google's generative-AI guide addresses.
That gap matters more than the listicle format itself. Google is telling marketers to measure success by leads and sales rather than unproven visibility scores, at the same moment an entire category of GEO and AEO tools has built dashboards around measuring exactly that kind of score. The objection from SEOs wasn't to writing fewer lists. It was that a vendor's visibility number is being treated as a stand-in for the pipeline metric Google just told CMOs to track instead.
What a software marketer should do
Most SaaS content calendars are full of the format Kraham is describing: "Top 10 CRM features," "Best project management tools for startups," "10 ways to improve onboarding." None of that is inherently wrong, but Google is signaling that commodity versions of it are losing ground to content built from a vendor's own usage data, support tickets, or implementation work — the kind of detail a competitor can't simply rewrite.
The second half of the advice is the one worth acting on first. Before the next GEO or AEO vendor pitch lands, decide what you're actually measuring: pipeline and closed revenue, or a visibility score the vendor itself calculates. Google just told CMOs to trust the former. The SEO community's loudest objection this week wasn't to that idea — it was that too few marketing teams have made the switch.
Audit planned "Top X" posts against Kraham's test: does each point reflect something your team actually learned, or could a competitor have written it from a search results page? Reroute the posts that fail toward product usage data, support patterns, or implementation specifics. And before adopting any AI-visibility or AEO score as a KPI, confirm it correlates with pipeline in your own funnel — not just with the vendor selling it.
Salesforce's CEO declared SEO dead to sell an AI-visibility tool, and his own company's guide disagrees
Sienna Mcpherson · 4 min read
Tools & AnalyticsIntuit sells Mailchimp to Bending Spoons for $3.68 billion
Sienna Mcpherson · 4 min read
AI